Author Topic: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)  (Read 25214 times)

guest1428

  • Guest
Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« on: May 29, 2010, 05:02:22 AM »
From my searches on the internet it seems I may be the only person with this quite major Jazz fault… lucky me  :(

I have had my 2004 Jazz 1.4 Manual (41K miles), for almost 3 years and this is the first problem its had. I’m looking for any help advice about the fault itself or how my Honda dealer is handling it.

Fault Description
I have a reoccurring fault where the engine warning light comes on and I loose all control of the throttle. Sometimes the engine stays at idle even if my foot is on the floor (leaving me stranded) or the throttle revs up and down on its own as if it is possessed. No amount of pumping the throttle up and down does anything, the car decides itself what throttle it wants.

Turning the engine off for a few minutes and then back on again sometimes returns throttle control, but the warning light stays on.

It mostly seems to occur on coldish (above freezing) mornings a few minutes after setting off, but it just went through a whole winter of starting covered in snow so I don’t know how significant ambient temperature is really having.

It has been looked at by the AA, been in a specialist engine tuning garage twice and to Honda once so far. When the fault first occurred it had error code po638 Throttle Actuator Control. This was cleared and when it had the problem a second time the specialist garage said the error didn’t show on the national database. That’s when it went off to Honda. My Honda invoice says error code po039 and they replaced the throttle body and egr at the cost of just shy of £1000…

The cost hurt, but I could put up with it knowing that I would now have years of happy motoring. It lasted just under two weeks before the fault came back again…

My nearest Honda dealer is Brayley Honda (Enfield, UK). I don’t feel safe driving it and asked them to collect it, they refused and said I had to arrange it. I was going to get it transported there, but now they say that they cant look at it for over a week because they are too busy. I’m not sure what my rights are, but I would think that they should at least look at it immediately as their repair must still be under warranty and I cant drive it safely?

My car is sitting in the car park at the moment and I am just too scared to drive it. I’ve twice been caught by the fault occurring half way to work and its not pleasant when the throttle decides to take control, its like being in Christine. At least I have a manual, if this was an auto I think I may have had an accident by now…


Any advice about the fault or how to get my dealer to actual fix this problem would me much appreciated. I bought a Jazz because I expected it to be super reliable, in some ways its now worse than the old bangers I had when I was a teen   ::)

Many Thanks in advance,

John

guest255

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #1 on: May 29, 2010, 06:28:57 AM »
I used to have a Vauxhall Nova with a similar problem and Vauxhall couldn't find what was wrong.

So I decided to replace the throttle position sensor and 'bingo' it worked!

Check to see if this has been checked/replaced


guest1428

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #2 on: May 29, 2010, 10:29:46 AM »
Thanks JazzyB, I will mention that when I take it in to the dealer.

They did already replace the Throttle Body, and from what I understood it sounded like this was the unit that the cable from the foot peddle attaches to and includes the sensor part. Is this what you mean by a 'throttle position sensor' or is that further down the chain of parts to the actual engine?

Im hoping that they arent going to tell me I need to replace something else as well as Ive already paid 1K, espeicially if they are just guessing. It doesnt make much sense that it worked fine for two weeks after they gave it back... unless all they did was clear the error and fit parts that werent needed and the fault has just been waiting to reoccur since then...  ???

guest255

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #3 on: May 29, 2010, 01:40:43 PM »
The throttle position sensor is part of the throttle body. Unfortunately its not available separately hence the steep price!

I would take it straight back as the repair would have at least 1 years warranty.

Don't pay anymore money for a fault that still appears to be there.




fisherman

  • Approved Member
  • *
  • Posts: 40
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #4 on: May 29, 2010, 02:15:15 PM »
this may sound crazy, but our 1.4 auto became "tired" to start during the cold weather, I recharged the battery and this fixed it for a week or so but eventually it became hard to start again. At this point I renewed the battery, now it leaps into action, but more than that, before we had to increase revs with the throttle to get movement, now the tickover seems quicker and the car will creep away without touching the throttle. Is it possibly connected with more amps available keeping the sensors on thier toes?

culzean

  • Approved Member
  • *
  • Posts: 8017
  • Country: england
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #5 on: May 29, 2010, 10:05:24 PM »
Although on 1.2 / 1.4 GD manual the throttle butterfly is controlled directly by the cable from accelerator pedal (no drive by wire yet), the position sensor tells the ECU how far the butterfly is open and hence how much petrol to squirt into the system. The position sensor is normally a variable resistor (potentiometer) that feeds a voltage back to ECU that is proportional to throttle position. Without this feedback from the position sensor the ECU doesn't know what to do. 

It seems that the position sensor is calibrated to the throttle body during manufacture and can't be bought seperately............. :( 
Some people will only consider you an expert if they agree with your point of view or advice,  when you give them advice they don't like they consider you an idiot

culzean

  • Approved Member
  • *
  • Posts: 8017
  • Country: england
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #6 on: May 29, 2010, 10:21:58 PM »
Quote
this may sound crazy, but our 1.4 auto became "tired" to start during the cold weather     

Unless you pay megabucks for a Bosch 'silver' or calcium battery your cars battery will be living on borrowed time after about 4 years.  The battery will get 'tired' and will not produce enough amps to start the car properly in cold weather - even a small engine like the Jazz can demand 250+ amps from a battery. Buy the biggest, heaviest battery you can get into the space - I have squeezed in a 330CCA (Cold Cranking Amps are rated at -18degC with system voltage not dropping below 8volts). 

A bosch silver or a calcium battery will give about 30% CCA and reserve capacity (Ampere/ hours) more than a standard lead/acid for a given size of battery.

The system voltage will be better with a new battery and all the sensors will be getting their proper voltage.
Some people will only consider you an expert if they agree with your point of view or advice,  when you give them advice they don't like they consider you an idiot

guest1428

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #7 on: May 30, 2010, 05:21:05 AM »
this may sound crazy, but our 1.4 auto became "tired" to start during the cold weather, I recharged the battery and this fixed it for a week or so but eventually it became hard to start again. At this point I renewed the battery, now it leaps into action, but more than that, before we had to increase revs with the throttle to get movement, now the tickover seems quicker and the car will creep away without touching the throttle. Is it possibly connected with more amps available keeping the sensors on thier toes?

Hi fisherman, I think I actually know the answer to your problem. I had to change my battery as it got very weak after the hard winter we just had in the UK. Luckily I had a look in the Haynes manual as just changing the battery on the Jazz is filled with potential problems...

For starters you have to retrain the ECM, below is the recommended procedure given by Haynes:

1.   Run Engine at 3000 rpm until engine warm.
2.   Run Engine idle for 5min with all loads turned off.
3.   Lastly drive the car normally for at least 5min.

Haynes also warns that occationally changing the battery can produce a fault in the power steering which needs a lengthly procedure to fix... lucky for me it didnt occur on mine.

Im not sure what happens if you dont train the ECM properly, but Haynes states that the training sets the idle speed so that might be the cause of your problem.

Back to my problem

Haynes mentions 3 sensors to do with throttle (Section 4A.11 if you have it) Throttle position sensor, Throttle actuator and Acceleration pedal position sensor. Does anyone know if these are automatically replaced by getting the Throttle body and EGR replaced (which is what shows on my invoice) or are any of these seperate units that may be the cause of my problem?



guest255

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #8 on: May 30, 2010, 10:14:22 AM »
Seeing has you have the Haynes manual turn to pages 4A.2 and 4A.3  because some models have an 'electronic throttle control system'


guest1328

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #9 on: May 30, 2010, 11:44:44 AM »
Quote
Hi fisherman, I think I actually know the answer to your problem. I had to change my battery as it got very weak after the hard winter we just had in the UK. Luckily I had a look in the Haynes manual as just changing the battery on the Jazz is filled with potential problems...

For starters you have to retrain the ECM, below is the recommended procedure given by Haynes:
Quote
1.   Run Engine at 3000 rpm until engine warm.
2.   Run Engine idle for 5min with all loads turned off.
3.   Lastly drive the car normally for at least 5min.

Haynes also warns that occationally changing the battery can produce a fault in the power steering which needs a lengthly procedure to fix... lucky for me it didnt occur on mine.

Im not sure what happens if you dont train the ECM properly, but Haynes states that the training sets the idle speed so that might be the cause of your problem.



Good Grief !  Just to change a battery!  Makes you wonder whether contact breakers and simple carbs. were such a bad idea!  




guest1428

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #10 on: May 30, 2010, 01:41:26 PM »
Seeing has you have the Haynes manual turn to pages 4A.2 and 4A.3  because some models have an 'electronic throttle control system'

OK, so models with ETCS have a pedal position sensor mounted below the throttle body. Models without ETCS just have a straight connection between the pedal and throttle body.

Is there an easy way to tell which I have, I mean without having to crawl under the car?

guest1428

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #11 on: June 05, 2010, 03:54:41 AM »
It does sound crazy, but this is what Brayley Honda in Enfield are trying to tell me is wrong with my 2004 Jazz 1.4SE Manual.

The car went back to Brayley Honda on Thursday for the second time (cost me about £120 to get it transported there). They dragged their feet so much last time, I’ve hired a car to cover me for the next week (another £170). They have already had £1000 from me to allegedly fix the problem three weeks ago. So costs are really stacking up now.

I changed the battery after getting it back from them last time (this was three weeks ago now). It ran fine for two weeks (used daily) and had no problem with idle. Now its back with them for the same problem as before: erratic idle and no response from throttle (foot to floor = no change in rpm). But unfortunately it doesn’t do it all the time so Honda haven’t seen it in action yet...

They are trying to fob me off by implying that changing the battery caused this problem. My understanding of the ECM relearning process is that even if you don’t do a relearning process (which I did according to the Haynes recommendations - REF.7 if you have it) the worst that might happen is that you get erratic idle and bad fuel economy.

I’ve spent hours searching the net trying to find possible causes for this fault and I’ve tried to talk to Brayley Honda, but they refuse to let me speak to an engineer. The Lantern towing guy that transported my car saw the fault in action and said it seemed like a “air flow sensor” problem to him and “the engine was trying to suck in air which is making the idle irregular”. I tried to suggest they investigate this and I received this statement from Siobhan Downes (Service advisor) in return: “if we don’t have a fault code we cant just start disassembling parts to investigate a problem”.

They did have a fault code when I brought it in on Thursday, all I could get out of them re the code was that it was a result of the battery change. Which I think is rubbish…

Brayley Honda are refusing to tell me what the fault code was when I brought it back to them (I suspect because it was the same one as the first time I brought it in or they cleared it without recording what it was).

I am looking for ammunition to argue with them about this, has anyone heard of a throttle problem appearing 250miles and 2 weeks after changing a battery? This sounds like pure fantasy to me.

fisherman

  • Approved Member
  • *
  • Posts: 40
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #12 on: June 06, 2010, 07:43:20 AM »
As I said in the previos post I was forced to change the battery on the wife's Fit, I just unhooked the old one and fitted the new one, the only difference I have noticed is that the Auto choke is working better now, no throttle required to creep off the driveway. When warmed up is as it was before. Are the Fits different in some repect?? ours came from Japan pre owned.

guest1428

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #13 on: June 07, 2010, 04:21:16 PM »
Just got the news I was dreading from Enfield Honda. They say they believe they have fixed the problem by retraining the ECM, which I consider nonsense. Finally managed to talk to the engineer and had a long conversation, he made up some weird story about how changing a battery can lock the system so there was no throttle. When I told him I had driven 2 weeks and 250miles without problem since the battery change he went silent for a while – then went back in to repeating over and over how he believed the problem was now fixed and we wont be bringing it back again. This is what I was told last time.

Breaking down four times with the same problem, in the garage four times, twice transported because I cant even drive it, looked at by the AA, multiple taxi and hire car costs not to mention the £1000 I paid for parts that didn’t fix the problem – I’ve had enough.

My current plan is to pickup the car and immediately sell it before it goes wrong again. I’ve insisted they give me a receipt that states they have fixed the fault I brought it in for, someone else can continue this battle. I work full time and am studying a University course, I don’t have time to play their games. The treatment I’ve had by Honda over the years is just pathetic and I don’t intend to ever buy a Honda again. I’m going out and buying a new Toyota as soon as possible.

This plan is subject to the car working long enough for me to be able to sell it of course…

guest255

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Re: Throttle has a mind of its own (errors po638 po039)
« Reply #14 on: June 07, 2010, 07:39:27 PM »
I’m going out and buying a new Toyota as soon as possible.



Toyota??

Are you sure with their quality record at the moment............

Tags:
 

Back to top