Author Topic: Auto jazz "flaring" - downshifting, revving, sometimes cutting out completely.  (Read 5385 times)

guest6727

  • Guest
Hi all,

My friend's automatic Jazz has this problem. Sometimes when driving at speed, usually above 30 mph and up to dual carriageway speeds, the gearbox seems to slip down to a lower gear, revving loads and losing power. I believe this is known as "flaring". Often it does it a few times before returning to normal, but sometimes it results in the engine cutting out or losing power completely and she has to pull over on the dual carriageway.

I just tried the EGR valve tonight - fitted a blanking plate but this did not solve the problem. I'll give the valve a clean anyway and take the blanking plate out.

She took it to a garage a few weeks back and they tried flushing the transmission fluid (although I don't know how many times they did this - I read that you often need to do it a few times) and they also tried replacing the range switch (at a cost to my friend of £200) and this did not solve the problem either. So I think the garage decided the starter clutch needed replacing, at a cost of £900, which is half the value of the car.

Any other ideas we could try before she gets rid of it?

guest1372

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Some Jazz models with an electronic throttle body have suffered from a temperamental wiring fault in the cable leading to it.  This causes strange throttle behaviour under very unique or particular circumstances that may be related to temperature or angle or g-force or the position of the engine on it's mounts etc.  One of the wires is slightly too short (often yellow/green), and where it passes through a 90° bend in the conduit the inner conductor stretches and eventually breaks.  This leads to an intermittent connection that might only become apparent in rare circumstances.  The fault produces an error code, this may not illuminate the check engine light if the wire makes contact again soon after, but the codes should be stored and may be checked later.  For any codes related to throttle position sensor - this is the most likely culprit.  The fix is simple - cut and re-join the cable, but it's difficult to reach as it goes down the back of the engine underneath the airbox.

If you can plug in an OBDII code reader above the driver's pedals (search Amazon/Ebay for ELM327 e.g. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/222415636277) you may be able to narrow down the source of this issue.
--
TG

guest1372

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
A simple check may be wiggling the cable that exits from the bottom of the throttle body and seeing if the revs are disrupted or if a code is triggered.
More thorough is checking for a constant 5v between pins 1 & 2 of the plug as shown while flexing the cable particularly where the smaller conduit joins the larger one. (Engine off but key in position IG1)
--
TG

[attachment deleted by admin]

guest6727

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Sounds interesting. I've got an OBDII reader so I'll check the codes asap. Are you guys thinking that the transmission is a red herring? The garage seemed fixated on it (they didn't check the common EGR valve problem for example).

guest6727

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Alright so the only code in the ecu was "insufficient EGR lift" which must surely be due to the blanking plate being on during the test drive last night. Well I've cleared it and removed the blanking plate and given the egr valve a good clean so we'll see if it comes back.

There were no other codes. That strikes me as a bit weird.

I gave the cable to the throttle body a good wiggle and couldn't make anything strange happen.

guest6727

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
Thinking about the codes. It's odd because she said that the check engine light has come on sometimes. So shouldn't there have been a code?? Unless it was the EGR valve after all, but I don't think that should be a problem at motorway speeds?

guest1372

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
I think EGR has got a reputation that is worse than reality suggests, when it was introduced many were obsessed with defeating it.   I think it is a bit more binary - either it's sticking or it isn't.  If the valve position differs to that requested then a code is triggered; also it's effect can be sensed downstream.  I can't see it leading to the symptoms originally described. 

There are a couple of rotation speed sensors on the CVT, someone on here last year needed to change one but I don't know what the symptoms were.  I mention the throttle body cable fault as it's quite common on 2004/5 cars and causes erratic running that is often diagnosed as other £££ faults by garages leading to many unnecessary replacement parts. 

I also think some fault codes are cleared automatically when a certain number of acceptable readings are received in sequence.
--
TG

guest6727

  • Topic Starter
  • Guest
OK thanks for clearing that up. Initially she said the problem only occurred at low revs and that sounded a lot like what people reported for the EGR valve. But now I know it also happens at high speed.

Interesting regarding the codes. I'll have to sit in the car with the OBD connected and try and catch the code when it happens I guess.

Tags:
 

Back to top