Clubjazz - Honda Jazz & HR-V Forums

Other Hondas & General Topics => Honda & Other Honda Models => Topic started by: Karoq on October 14, 2023, 06:53:46 PM

Title: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Karoq on October 14, 2023, 06:53:46 PM
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/honda/eny1 3 year warranty.

Bigger, Better, cheaper, bigger battery, longer range.
is the:-
https://www.carwow.co.uk/kia/niro-ev-estate.  7 year warranty.
Come on Honda. Get your backside in gear!
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Westy36 on October 14, 2023, 11:14:21 PM
And what exactly does a journo star rating mean? Nothing. My car, rated 3/5 by the same publication, has nearly 130k fault free miles under its belt. I wonder how many 5/5 star, invariably German motors, can say that?

Mind at best part of £50k, I would call that motor a tricky sell. Personally, I'd save myself £30k and buy a nearly new Jazz. If I had to have a new car, again, save £30k and buy a Dacia. 4 wheels and keeps the rain off you. Who's going to spend best part of £50k on 4.4m 'yawn all the same' small suv? 

Honda need to rediscover some value and extend their warranties to get some volume sales. £50k small ev's are a bit niche in image obsessed UK. Sadly.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Kremmen on October 15, 2023, 05:30:05 AM
Agree

It is well known that journos give better ratings to vehicle manufacturers that advertise in their rag

I remember reading a side by side lengthy review once where it was clear that car A was better than car B. Move to the final verdict section where car B came out on top, why, because car B was a VAG and they had multiple adverts running through the rag
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Lord Voltermore on October 15, 2023, 07:48:20 AM
Cars progress.  Its inevitable that some new cars  on the market may impress motoring  journalists in some ways.  Cars that got 5 stars last year  are  downgraded otherwise they would have to award the new one 6 stars. etc. 

 Fair enough so far. Except motoring journalists are notorious for raving about different 'qualities' than real world owners. Or rate things based on  specification numbers  , not real world competence  .  And for copying each others reviews and may never have actually driven a Jazz , or even the new kid on the block.

That said I expect Honda pay attention to competitors. As will I when the time comes to change the Jazz.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Bristol_Crosstar on October 15, 2023, 09:15:56 AM
Honda haven't quite hit the mark with their EV offerings, when you consider an HR-V with similar spec can be bought for under £35K it's difficult to justify the extra expense when the hybrid driving experience is hardly any different to an EV.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Karoq on October 15, 2023, 09:37:48 AM
And what exactly does a journo star rating mean? Nothing. My car, rated 3/5 by the same publication, has nearly 130k fault free miles under its belt. I wonder how many 5/5 star, invariably German motors, can say that?
[/quote

The star rating has absolutely nothing to do with reliability. All newly reviewed cars are NEW! so no idea of reliability.
The star rating is the car in general, comfort, road holding, speed, Comparison with other eVs re charging rates, range etc. Boot space, practicality blah, blah,blah.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Lincolnshire Rambler on October 15, 2023, 10:30:00 AM
As a teenager I was lucky to have the MOTOR magazine bought for me by my mother and so spend many hours reading some great articles . Journalists such as Peter Dron and Russell Bulgin had an enormous appetite for cars and said it how it was -in a totally objective and professional way. Supported by long term car tests it showed what could go wrong in daily use . A poor Volvo 240 had the biggest list of issues ever as I recall. And a new ford escort 1.4 was driven 5000 miles in a very short space of time ( was it a week??) with no faults . Seldom do we read such good stuff today !
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: coravel on October 15, 2023, 10:35:32 AM
Agree

It is well known that journos give better ratings to vehicle manufacturers that advertise in their rag

I remember reading a side by side lengthy review once where it was clear that car A was better than car B. Move to the final verdict section where car B came out on top, why, because car B was a VAG and they had multiple adverts running through the rag

The media are there to manipulate us but we mustn't fall for their lies. 
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: RichardA on October 15, 2023, 10:41:33 AM
As a teenager I was lucky to have the MOTOR magazine bought for me by my mother and so spend many hours reading some great articles . Journalists such as Peter Dron and Russell Bulgin had an enormous appetite for cars and said it how it was -in a totally objective and professional way. Supported by long term car tests it showed what could go wrong in daily use . A poor Volvo 240 had the biggest list of issues ever as I recall. And a new ford escort 1.4 was driven 5000 miles in a very short space of time ( was it a week??) with no faults . Seldom do we read such good stuff today !


Russell Bulgin is before my time but I've heard great stories about him. His interview with Nigel Mansell is supposed to be the stuff of legends.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: embee on October 15, 2023, 10:41:56 AM
I know all things are relative,  but I just feel the current crop of (electric) cars are simply too much money. I say that rather than too expensive because the word "expensive " is a subjective thing,  too much money is just that.
Everyone is different and things move on, but I suspect a large sector of the public don't really want nor need a whole host of the gizmos we now get in a car. £50k for an "ordinary " car?

A few gizmos do feature on my list,  leccy windows, a radio, and remote central locking,  but frankly not much more. I want passive safety stuff,  ABS airbags etc, but active cruise control isn't high on the list though I realise once you add some sort of distance sensor then other apps come almost for free,  just software in effect.

I suppose I'm now the proverbial "old far*" but I'm feeling a growing hatred of oversized SUVs, just way too big, especially too wide, to the point of being a hazard.
I digress ..........
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Kremmen on October 15, 2023, 11:04:48 AM
I regularly see a certain demographic of person trying to parallel park a SUV into a tight spot for that size of vehicle

Many instances where a long queue of traffic builds up as they constantly get the angle wrong and perform over a dozen front and back manoeuvres and even then they are parked crooked

In my Jazz I could have done it in a single manoeuvre
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: coldstart on October 15, 2023, 12:52:14 PM
... trying to parallel park a SUV into a tight spot for that size of vehicle ...
SUV  =  Specially Unwieldy Vehicule ?   ;D
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Nicksey on October 15, 2023, 03:25:46 PM
... trying to parallel park a SUV into a tight spot for that size of vehicle ...
SUV  =  Specially Unwieldy Vehicule ?   ;D

Stupidly useless vehicle  8)

All the aesthetics and aero dynamics of a breeze block.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Kremmen on October 15, 2023, 04:57:46 PM
When I see a large SUV with just one person I think of the phrase 'poser mode'

Just like those who drive round 24/7 with front fog lights blazing away
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: richardfrost on October 15, 2023, 05:51:07 PM
When I see a large SUV with just one person I think of the phrase 'poser mode'

Look here my good man. There are times when the chauffeur has to drive the car without me in it you know, what what.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: olduser1 on October 15, 2023, 09:19:31 PM
The future for drivers Jazz with motor bike petrol engine light weight built in max retail £11.5k. Form a queue.
Hybrid & electric vehicles are designed to sell your data on 10 times over, don't even go near how to put out a fire out in car park in a tunnel on board a ship/ ferry.
Journalists sometimes just copy to press release......
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Kremmen on October 16, 2023, 04:26:16 AM
 :D
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Lord Voltermore on October 16, 2023, 07:56:55 AM
Sitting in an SUV, sports utility vehicle,   with room for your body size to expand is the same as being sporty?
I have a neighbour who drives his SUV a few hundred metres to buy cigarettes and then home again.
I have seen posters for a betting company that features people riding exercise bikes.  So betting is also active sport.  Unless you can bet on how soon someone who drives their SUV to a gym keels over. 

Rant over.  I am going for a walk.     
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Karoq on October 16, 2023, 11:47:59 AM
I must admit that my last 3 cars have had active CC and I never use it. Perhaps because I rarely go far enough.
i did try it once on a long run and found it LESS economic than non use. The reason is that the car will keep at the requested speed come hell or high water, uphill and down dale. Whereas YOU driving can chose how you approach hills both up and down and let the car go into overrun downhill, saving petrol which the CC won't allow. 
As far as active safety features are concerned, emergency braking both at low and high speed are a must have. It saved me hitting a pedestrian on a dark afternoon, she under trees wearing black walking on the verge of a dark country lane with no footpath.
Lane keep assist is frankly a pain in the @rse and I turn mine off. Blind spot monitoring 10/10!.
Each unto their own.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: Lincolnshire Rambler on October 16, 2023, 06:38:57 PM
What an interesting comment from “old user” - it wouldn’t be too far away for Honda to match a motorcycle engine to power the hybrid generator instead of a “ car engine “ quite a few 7 style kit cars already use mc engines . They have lots of power and revs but low torque which in our hybrid world is counteracted with the electric motor drive . Yes I’d buy a lighter no frills jazz with a 600 cc 80 PS motor cycled engines hybrid . How easy would it be to design out 100kg of weight … ?
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: coldstart on October 16, 2023, 08:40:12 PM
What an interesting comment from “old user” - it wouldn’t be too far away for Honda to match a motorcycle engine to power the hybrid generator instead of a “ car engine “ quite a few 7 style kit cars already use mc engines . They have lots of power and revs but low torque which in our hybrid world is counteracted with the electric motor drive . Yes I’d buy a lighter no frills jazz with a 600 cc 80 PS motor cycled engines hybrid . How easy would it be to design out 100kg of weight … ?
You know that the "downsizing" days died with WLTP? Only the older NEDC was in favour of smaller engines which in reality were inefficient to say the least! Since the inception of WLTP the maufacturer-stated fuel efficency is much closer to reality than ever before (depending on how heavy your right foot is)  :D
btw: The Jazz's Atkinson-cycle ICE is already highy optimized with an efficency factor of up to 40% whereas a motorcycle engine usually s optimized for revs and power.
Title: Re: Oh Dear! Is this the beginning of the end for Honda? Only 3*/5
Post by: richardfrost on October 17, 2023, 08:58:20 AM
Sounds like a range extender design to me, like BMW used to fit in their early 'electric' vehicles, before Toyota made all their hybrid designs open source.