I would go for the Golf, I am on my 15th VW, allways found them to be excellent , the only thing that I would say is test drive it, that 1 litre
engine is the least powerfull unit in the Golf range. I have that engine in my Polo, which is a superb drive, but the Golf
is a bigger car. You are not likely to get positive vote for a VW on a Honda forum, but they are really good drive, we
have the Mk2 Jazz as well, no problems with that either, but VW drive is much smoother, the suspension is
softer and more suited to our shocking roads.