I got my renewal from Lloyds today for £412. I had already had quotes from Confused.com including one from Lloyds for £349. I called Lloyds to discuss the matter and was told that the best they could do was £398 but that if I had a better quote from Confused then go for that as it is treated as new business. This I did and confirmed with Lloyds that I was not renewing. I gave them my new policy number which was then checked and was confirmed to be OK so I saved £63. The crazy world of insurance.
If you were inclined to stay with the same company, it's worth noting that Lloyds Insurance is operated by BISL (Budget Insurance) as a white-label service, and that there are many other companies on the comparison sites that are exactly the same - so check out all of the quotes from the other BISL motor insurance brands - Halifax, RAC, Post Office, Bradford & Bingley, Yes Insurance, HSBC, Barclays, Autotrader, Bennetts, Pearl, Dial Direct, Ecoinsurance, iBuyeco, Pearl, and of course Budget. There are probably more.