I switched to rubber mats, partly due to some of the muddy places I end up, and they have outlasted my previous sets of cloth mats by probably 3x, no peg holes but the spiked backs keep them exactly in place. I will put the deep pile cloth mats back in if I ever sell this car, because the rubber is a bit 'transit van'.
Must say the black trim with chrome accents is so much better than the blue interior.
--
TG